Deed thieves don't pick homes at random. They go after property whose owner lives far away, gets no monthly mortgage statement or has recently died1,2.
This guide starts our section on the owners most at risk. It shows which properties title companies see targeted, why criminals choose them and the free steps that fit each kind of owner.
Who is most at risk of deed theft?
Owners of land or homes they don't live in face the most risk. In spring 2026, the American Land Title Association (ALTA) surveyed 245 title insurance professionals in 40 states. 82% of their firms rated vacant land at least a somewhat common target of seller impersonation fraud1.
That's the kind of deed theft where a criminal poses as the owner to sell a property.
Vacation homes, rentals and lived-in homes gained the most
Share of title firms rating each type a common target of seller impersonation fraud in 2026, with the rise since ALTA's 2024 survey in points
Show the numbers
| Vacant land | 82% |
|---|---|
| Vacation home | 51% (up 14) |
| Rental property | 48% (up 11) |
| Agricultural land | 36% (up 13) |
| Primary residence | 25% (up 13) |
| Commercial property | 13% |
Source: ALTA Critical Issues Study: Seller Impersonation Fraud, September 14, 2026. "Common" means somewhat common, common or very common.1
Living in your home doesn't take it off the list. Primary residences gained 13 points since ALTA's 2024 survey. Vacation homes, rentals and agricultural land also rose by more than 10 points each1.
Who owns a property matters as much as what it is. ALTA asked about owners for the first time in 2026.
Properties with absentee owners were rated at least somewhat common targets by 72% of firms. Next came properties owned free and clear, with no mortgage (68%), and properties of people who recently died (55%)1.
Why do criminals pick these properties?
Fewer people are in a position to notice. ALTA explains the pattern this way:
Criminals often target transactions that present fewer opportunities for direct interaction with property owners or involve owners who live outside the local market, both of which can make identity verification more challenging.
A home with no loan has one less set of eyes on it. California's Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI) says fraudsters often pick owners with low mortgage account activity, so changes are harder to spot.
It names elderly, recently deceased and absentee owners as the most at risk. They're more likely to have a paid-off home or to own a vacant or rental property2.
Public records give criminals a starting point. The FBI says they gather owners' details from county or state websites, data brokers, phishing and stolen data.
Then they pose as the owner with fake IDs, new email accounts and internet phone numbers. They contact real agents and title companies to sell the land3. The FBI's June 2026 warning on vacant land lists the warning signs buyers and agents should watch for.
Which owners are most at risk?
Eight kinds of owners come up again and again in the research. Where ALTA measured it, the figure on each card is the share of title firms that rated it at least a somewhat common target in 2026.
Vacant land
No one lives there to notice a listing or a buyer walking the lot. The FBI's June 2026 warning was about fake owners selling vacant parcels3.Owners who live elsewhere
Out-of-state owners and many landlords. Rental property on its own was rated a common target by 48% of firms1.Paid-off homes
No monthly statement and no lender in the picture. Here's what to do after you pay off your mortgage.Homes of owners who died
More than a third of firms said criminals' use of death certificates was at least somewhat common. 60% rated a deceased title holder a common red flag, up from 36% in 20241.Second homes
Vacation homes can sit empty for weeks or months. They gained 14 points since 2024, the biggest jump of any property type1.Older owners
California's regulator lists elderly owners first among those most at risk2. The New York Times says homes owned by older people may be especially vulnerable4.Homes in a trust or a company
The record may name the trust or the company, so a search for your own name can miss a filing. Firms saw corporate entity fraud more often than in 20241.The home you live in
The least common home target in the survey, but it gained 13 points since 20241.How common is deed theft?
It's rare, and no one tracks it well. The New York Times reported in November 2026 that "it's not clear how common deed theft is nationally."
The FBI estimates it received 66 complaints about deed or title theft in 2025, with $5.9 million in losses. From January through October 2026, it received 75 complaints, with losses of almost $7 million4.
Title companies see far more attempts than that. FBI complaints count only the cases people report. ALTA's survey also counts attempts that failed, not just the ones that worked.
of title firms saw at least one attempt at seller impersonation fraud in 2025. In ALTA's 2024 survey, that share was 28%.
Source: ALTA Critical Issues Study: Seller Impersonation Fraud, September 14, 20261
Most cases don't involve the home someone lives in. A 2025 survey of Realtor association staff by the National Association of Realtors (NAR) found that "only 12 percent of cases involved owner-occupied homes." Residential land made up 52% of cases5.
NAR says its samples are small, so treat these numbers as a rough guide.
How can each type of owner lower the risk?
Three free steps help every owner. Search your county's records under your name. Keep your mailing address current with the assessor and the tax collector.
And sign up for your county's free alert if it has one, so you hear when a document is recorded in your name. San Diego County's recorder gives owners the same advice6.
Then add the step that fits your property:
| If you own | A free step that fits | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Vacant land | Check the county record and the tax bill's mailing address every few months | No one is on site to see a listing or a buyer |
| A rental or an out-of-town home | Make sure tax bills and county mail come to you, not to the property | Mail sent to the property may never reach you |
| A second home | Ask a neighbor to call you about signs, crews or visitors you didn't expect | The home can sit empty for months |
| A paid-off home | Confirm the lender's release was recorded, then set up an alert | No mortgage statement will show you a change |
| A late parent's home | Keep the taxes paid and search the record under the owner's name | A deceased owner is a red flag title firms see more often |
| A home in a trust or a company | Sign up for alerts under the trust's or company's name too | A search for your own name can miss a filing |
Alerts can watch more than your own name. San Diego County puts it this way: "If your property title is held individually, in a trust, or under a business name, you can register using any of those names." Its free Owner Alert takes up to 10 names and 10 parcel numbers for each email address6.
Not every county has an alert yet. In California, every county recorder must run one starting January 1, 2027, under Senate Bill 2552. To see what your county offers today, check our list of county property fraud alerts.
Not sure you need a paid service at all? Our guide on whether home title lock is necessary weighs the free options against the paid ones.
Figures and links on this page were checked on November 16, 2026.
Frequently asked questions about deed theft risk
Can someone sell your house without you knowing?
Not legally, but criminals try by posing as the owner. The FBI's June 2026 warning describes fake owners of vacant land who use forged IDs to sell it through real agents and title companies3. If a fake deed is ever filed on your home, follow our steps for what to do if a fraudulent deed is filed.
Can your home title be stolen if you have a mortgage?
Yes, because a mortgage doesn't keep a criminal from forging a deed or posing as you. Still, title firms point to homes owned free and clear more often. 68% rated them at least a somewhat common target, and 86% rated no mortgage a common red flag in a sale1.
Is a home in a trust or an LLC safer from deed theft?
Not by itself. Title firms in ALTA's 2026 study reported fraud involving corporate entities more often than in 20241. If your home is held in a trust or a company, search the county record and sign up for alerts under that name as well as your own.
Are older homeowners more at risk of deed theft?
They can be. California's DFPI lists elderly owners among those most at risk, partly because they're more likely to own a paid-off home2. If you help an aging parent, look up the county record for their home once or twice a year.
What if I own land in another state?
You're the kind of owner the FBI's vacant land warning is about. It suggests checking whether the county's recorder or clerk sends a free email or text when a document is recorded in your name3. Also make sure the tax bill comes to your current address, since that's where the county sends notices.
Look up your property's record today
It takes a few minutes on your county's website. Then see whether your county will email you when a new document is filed in your name.
Find your county's free alertSources
- ALTA Critical Issues Study: Seller Impersonation Fraud, American Land Title Association, September 14, 2026
- Home Title Fraud: The Silent Heist That Could Steal Your House, California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, June 24, 2026
- Protect Your Property from Illegal Sales Through Parcel Owner Impersonation, FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, June 16, 2026
- Deed Theft Is Going Up as Rising Values Make Homes a Lucrative Target, Ann Carrns, The New York Times, November 13, 2026
- 2025 Deed and Title Fraud Survey, National Association of Realtors, May 29, 2025
- Owner Alert, San Diego County Assessor/Recorder/County Clerk, checked November 16, 2026

